Yes, it is a Reality TV show. Ratings and money are what drive the show. The definition of an American Idol? The singer who will make the most money for 19 and Fremantle. Do I love the show any less knowing that? No. In reality, small r not capital, at the end of the day, we all know that what makes good TV and money is not necessarily the best singer - i.e. Melinda Doolittle from Season 6. Do I wish it was different? Maybe. What if there were 24 equally talented singers, without ever having record deals, that were truly non-professional, with equal amounts of airtime, and judges who gave helpful advice to the contestants. Would you still watch?
So far, it is evident who the Chosen Ones are. Definition of Chosen Ones: Semi-professional, with proven performance skills in one or more areas, different from the previous year's winner in looks and genre, and highly promoted from the beginning. What about Kelly Clarkson? Season 1, there wasn't a proven American Idol formula nor established fanbases prior to the airing of the top 24. Wouldn't it be exciting if someone won, who had little promotion, that came out and surprised the heck out of everyone with "A Star is Born" moment!
Am I still watching? Yes! Wouldn't miss it for the world!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment